Tagged: lubricants

Common Lubrication Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Mistakes can happen all the time, but when we repeat them, they can become a habit or, worse, be viewed as a “best practice” within our industry. In the lubrication realm, there are a few common mistakes that occur quite frequently. In some cases, the operators may not understand or be aware of the full gravity of these mistakes. In this section, we will explore ways to avoid these mistakes.

Over-Lubrication vs. Under-Lubrication

“Some grease is better than no grease” is a common saying in the industry. However, there is such a thing as over-lubrication! Think about swimming pools. The pool usually has different levels: a minimum fill level, then a mid-tier level, and finally, the maximum level.

Common Lubrication Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Over-lubrication of a bearing

If we don’t fill it to the minimum level, it’s basically a puddle of water, not a swimming pool. We need a certain volume of water to function as a swimming pool. The same applies to our equipment.

We will under-lubricate our equipment if we do not provide enough grease or oil. In these cases, there is not enough lubricant to form the full required film to keep the two moving surfaces apart and perform all the lubricant functions. Therefore, there will be increased friction, wear, and heat, all leading to system inefficiencies.

On the other hand, if we filled the swimming pool beyond the maximum level, it would be pretty tricky for us to stand in it (while touching the bottom) or walk across the length of the pool without having lots of opposition from the water compared to walking across the length of the pool when it’s filled mid-way.

Something similar is happening with our equipment. If we over-lubricate it, we place additional stress on the components to perform extra work, as they must move on a thicker layer of lubricant, which will cause frictional losses. This can cause the equipment to heat up, leading to degradation of the lubricant and loss of efficiency.

Both over-lubrication and under-lubrication can be detrimental to your equipment. Instead, use the optimal level of lubricant, or (in the case of greases) use ultrasound to determine the required amount of grease for your application. In both cases, the ideal amount of lubricant is the volume at which the coefficient of friction is significantly lowered.

Choosing the Wrong Lubricant for the Application

Quite often, the wrong lubricant is chosen for the application. This can happen in several ways, whether unintentional or an error passed down through shift changes. Selecting the correct lubricant for your application begins with knowing the environmental and operational conditions and the equipment specifications.

Your first guide/resource should be the equipment’s OEM. They designed the equipment to perform within specific tolerance limits and can advise on the most appropriate lubricant given these tolerances. If they cannot be contacted, an alternative would be contacting your lubricant supplier to help determine the best lubricant based on their expertise with similar types of equipment in varying conditions.

Selecting the correct lubricant for your application begins with knowing the environmental and operational conditions and the equipment specifications.

Another misconception about selecting lubricants is that they should be chosen based on their initial cost. Instead, the total lifecycle cost of the lubricant should be considered, and the properties of the lubricant should also be factored into the decision-making process. The initial cost of the lubricant pales compared to the cost associated with unplanned downtimes, the short life span of the lubricant, and its disposal.

Inadequate Lubricant Storage and Handling

Lubricants should be handled with care. They can be affected by temperature, light, water, particulate, or even atmospheric contamination. They must be stored properly in a dry, clean, cool space (not exposed to the elements).

When transferring lubricants from larger containers into smaller ones, think of how you would perform this operation if you transferred blood from the blood bank to one of your family members. Would you use any container you found on the ground, or would you ensure that it is a sterilized container (needle or equipment)?

Lubricants can easily become contaminated with particulates, which can then be transferred to machines, leading to unplanned shutdowns. When transferring lubricants, it is critical to ensure that we do not introduce contaminants or transfer these contaminants to our equipment. We must keep the lubricants clean and free from contaminants.

Ignoring Environmental and Operational Conditions

Not all lubricants are created equally. Some are designed for harsher environments, while others can only function in regular operating conditions. Mineral oils can typically work in many circumstances. However, when higher temperatures or loads are involved, this may be a job more suited for a synthetic lubricant.

On the other hand, if the lubricants are geographically close to waterways or come into contact with them in any way, then these should be environmentally acceptable lubricants (EALs). Depending on the load and temperatures experienced by your equipment, your lubricant provider or OEM for the machinery can advise on the best-suited lubricant that will perform in these conditions.

Find out more in the full article, "Lubrication Explained: Types, Functions, and Examples" featured in Precision Lubrication Magazine by Sanya Mathura, CEO & Founder of Strategic Reliability Solutions Ltd.

Oil Properties

Lubrication Regimes: Understanding the Science of Lubrication

The primary purpose of lubrication is to create an acceptable lubricant film to sufficiently keep the two moving surfaces apart while allowing them to move with reduced friction. This is the ideal condition, but a lubricant can undergo a couple of different regimes before it achieves this full film format.

The figure below shows the overall relationship between film thickness and the related regime and the associated regime relationships with the coefficient of friction.

Lubrication Regimes Understanding the Science of Lubrication

Stribeck curve showing the friction levels associated with the various lubrication regimes from Lubricants and Lubrication, Second, Completely Revised and Extended Edition edited by Theo Mang and Wilfried Dresel (2007)

Boundary Lubrication

At startup or rest, lubricants are usually residing in the sump. For this example, let us think about a car at rest. Since the vehicle has not moved, all the oil should have been drained and settled in its sump at the bottom of the engine. When the car starts, all the parts on the inside will begin moving.

Only after it starts does the oil begin its swift journey from the bottom of the sump to all the moving parts. That means that there is a delay between the oil getting to perform its function or reaching the moving parts.

In boundary lubrication, the oil has not fully formed its film, and there isn’t adequate separation of the asperities.

During boundary lubrication, the oil has not fully formed its film, and there isn’t adequate separation of the asperities. In this state, wear can still occur, and it is in this state that most wear occurs. A similar situation occurs during equipment shutdown, where the components also experience this boundary state of lubrication.

The figure at the side shows the various film conditions. In boundary lubrication (c), the asperities touch, whereas they are fully separated in (a).

Surface-active additives are critical for boundary lubrication and become activated under certain conditions. One of the most popular additives is EP (Extreme pressure) additives, which become activated when temperatures are increased (usually as a result of increased friction).

A surface film is typically formed during boundary lubrication. This can be the result of physical adsorption (physisorption), Chemical adsorption, or Chemical reactions involving or not involving stearate.

Different regimes as it relates to the lubricant

Physical adsorption occurs under mild sliding conditions with light loads and low temperatures. Chemical adsorption (chemisorption), stronger than physisorption, occurs when fatty acids react with metals to form soaps, which may or may not be attached to the surface.

On the other hand, chemical reactions that do not involve a substrate allow for slightly stronger bonds than chemisorption. However, with phosphorus-containing compounds, the phosphorus exists in a soluble carrier molecule that degrades at elevated temperatures, plates out on the metal surfaces, and forms a phosphorus soap (typically found in the Antiwear additive packages).

The last and strongest bonds to protect the surface are the chemical reactions involving a substrate where sulfide layers are formed on the surface. These provide low friction and good adhesive wear resistance⁵.

Mixed Lubrication

This state of lubrication exists as the lubricant transitions between Boundary and Full-Film lubrication. Its average film thickness is less than 1 but greater than 0.01μm. Some exposed asperities and roller element bearings can still experience this state during their start-stop cycles or if they are experiencing excessive or shock loads. These thin films are exposed to high shear conditions, leading to increased temperatures and reducing the lubricants’ viscosity⁶.

During this state, antiwear and EP additives protect the surfaces (similar to boundary lubrication). Most lubricants transition through this phase, and the additive packages must be able to help protect the surfaces.

Hydrodynamic Lubrication

Coefficient of Friction for the various regimes

During this regime, the two surfaces are usually fully separated. They are thick hydrodynamic fluid films that tend to be more than 0.001 inches (25μm) in depth, experiencing pressures between 50-300psi⁷. Ideally, friction only results from the shearing forces of a viscous lubricant⁸.

In this state, the surfaces are conformal, meaning that the angles between the intersecting surfaces remain unchanged. It is important to remember this, as it differentiates the hydrodynamic regime from the elastohydrodynamic regime. As shown in the figure below, the coefficient of friction changes for the various regimes, with the hydrodynamic regime having the lowest value.

Elastohydrodynamic Lubrication (EHL)

One of the main defining factors with EHL is that the oil’s viscosity must increase as the pressure on the oil increases, such that a supporting film must be established at the very high-pressure contact areas. Due to the pressure of the lubricant, elastic deformation of the two surfaces in contact will occur. These films are thin, typically around 10-50 μinches (0.25 – 1.25μm).

The surfaces in EHL are non-conformal (unlike Hydrodynamic lubrication), and the asperities of the contacting surfaces do not touch. However, the high pressures can deform either of the contacting surfaces to ensure that a full fluid film is maintained. This can increase the coefficient of friction.

Oil Properties

Types of Lubricants and Their Applications

Not all lubricants are created equally! In fact, they need to be designed differently for the various applications in which they are to be used. Typically, the overarching classification of lubricants can fall under either oil or grease. However, there are further categorizations that also include solid lubricants and specialty lubricants, as there are many varying applications of lubricants.

Oil Lubricants: Characteristics and Uses

Most of us are very familiar with oils. They are liquid; we use them in our cars or trucks, but what are they? An oil is comprised of base oil and additives. The additives can be used to either enhance, suppress, or add new characteristics to the base oils².

Types of Lubricants and Their Applications

Typically, oils can be used in many different applications and provide the advantages of having various viscosities according to the application3. These can range from oils with a viscosity similar to that of water to oils as thick as tar.

One of the main advantages of using oils as lubricants is their ability to dissipate heat from the system. Since they are fluid and circulate, they can “move” heat away from specific components and even help to remove some contaminants.

Oils can be used in gasoline-engine passenger cars, diesel-engine applications, circulating systems, turbines, gear applications, hydraulics, compressors, or even natural gas engines. Each application represents a different ratio of additives to base oils, ranging from 30% (motor oils) to a mere 1% additive (turbine oils).

Grease Lubricants: Advantages and Limitations

While the industry is familiar with oils as lubricants, there are some places where grease works better than oils! Greases are oils to which a thickener has been added. As such, they comprise base oil, additives, and thickener. The thickener holds the oil in place, allowing it to perform its main functions of reducing friction and providing lubrication.

One of the main advantages of greases is their ability to stay in one place. Consider a bearing placed at a 90° or 180° angle. If oil were used to lubricate this, it would drain out very easily. However, grease stays in place and still ensures that lubrication occurs.

While staying in place is a major advantage of grease, there are also some disadvantages to using it. A couple of those include the fact that grease cannot transfer heat away from components and keeps contaminants in place. These can both negatively impact the equipment.

Similar to oil, grease has different viscosities as per the NLGI (National Lubricating Grease Institute). These range from a 000 (almost the consistency of oil) to a 6 (similar to that of a block) and are all made for varying applications, as shown in the figure below.

While these viscosities define the application, one must also remember that the base oil viscosity can also differ. As such, operators must be mindful of NLGI grade, base oil viscosity, and additive package when selecting an appropriate grease.

Solid Lubricants: When and Why to Use Them

Why do we need a solid lubricant if we already have oils and greases in different states? Particular applications make these lubricants mandatory as they are the only ones that can meet the conditions and specifications involved.

Unlike oils or greases, these solid lubricants are designed to work in one lubrication regime, boundary lubrication⁴ (more on this later in the article). What sets these lubricants apart is their ability to form very thin films on the surfaces of moving components, which reduces friction due to their very low shear strength.

Some examples of solid lubricants include graphite, Molybdenum Disulfide (MoS2), Boren Nitride, and Fluoropolymer (PTFE). These solid lubricants can usually be used as grease additives (such as MoS2 for greases in mining with high load, low-speed applications) or even in the space industry for dry lubricant coatings on spacecraft.

Oil Properties

Lubrication Explained

What is Lubrication?

Lubrication is the process of reducing friction, wear, and heat between moving surfaces by introducing a lubricating substance, such as oil or grease.

The Purpose of Lubrication

If you walk into any industrial facility, you will find lubricants. While they come in all types of textures (greases or oils), viscosities, and packaging, one thing remains true: We need them. Lubricants were designed to reduce friction as their main function. However, that’s not their only use.

Although lubricants can effectively reduce friction, they can also reduce or transfer the heat built up in machines. This only applies to oils circulated through the systems and not grease that remains in place.

Additionally, lubricants can minimize wear by providing an adequate film to separate surfaces from rubbing on each other.

The 6 Functions of a Lubricant

Lubricants also help improve the efficiency of the machine by removing heat and reducing friction. They can also remove contaminants (for oils that are circulating, not grease) and transport them away from the machine’s internals. This is due to some additive technologies (such as dispersants or detergents).

Depending on the type of lubricant or its application, its function can also change. For instance, hydraulic oils are specifically used to transmit power, something that gear oils or motor oils cannot do. On the other hand, the lubricant can be considered a conduit of information if condition monitoring is considered.

Lubricants provide several functions depending on their application and environment. However, the main functions of a lubricant include reducing friction and wear, distributing heat, removing contaminants, and improving efficiency.

How Lubrication Reduces Friction and Wear

At the heart of lubrication is the main function of overcoming friction. When two parts move or two surfaces rub against each other, microscopic projections called asperities exist. Even on what appears to be smooth surfaces, asperities exist, and when these move over each other, friction is produced, which in turn can generate heat and cause wear.

Wear can typically occur in various forms, but in many of these, the touching of the asperities serves as the trigger point for wear to occur.

This is where lubricants really make a statement. They serve to provide a barrier between the two surfaces, almost allowing them to float over each other seamlessly. As such, friction is reduced once the asperities are kept apart, and this even influences a reduction in the occurrence of wear.

Wear can typically occur in various forms, but in many of these, the touching of the asperities serves as the trigger point for wear to occur. With the presence of the appropriate viscosity of lubricants, these asperities can be kept apart, and the occurrence of wear can be diminished significantly.

The Role of Lubrication in Preventive Maintenance

As we have noted above, proper lubrication can help to prevent wear. This is one of the many characteristics which make it ideally suited as a tool for preventive maintenance.

As defined, preventive maintenance can help maintenance professionals schedule time-based tasks / prescribed intervals¹. Any maintenance manual will include prescribed intervals at which lubricants should be changed (typically after 500 hours or 5000km).

OEMs (Original Equipment Manufacturers) defined these intervals as general guidelines for machine operators. This gives operators an idea of the lubricant’s expected life or the duration after which it would no longer be able to perform its functions adequately. By changing the lubricants at these intervals, one could avoid unplanned downtime.

Another aspect of lubrication associated with preventive maintenance is relubrication intervals. In some machines, there are minimum required reservoir levels that need to be maintained.

However, depending on the system, there may be some expected loss of lubricants during its lifetime. As such, relubrication intervals can help prevent unwanted downtime by injecting new oil or grease (with fresh additives) and maintaining the required reservoir levels.

Oil Properties / Storage & Handling of Lubricants

Storage and Handling & Advancements in Hydraulic oils

Hydraulic systems have smaller clearances than many. As such, it is imperative that these oils be kept clean and free from any debris. Most hydraulic components have a required ISO 4406 rating that should be met to ensure that the oils do not allow foreign particles to enter as these can easily clog the clearances and cause the system to stop working.

Chevron Lubricants produced a document that compiles some ISO 4406 codes for various types of industrial off highway equipment, which also includes the hydraulic standards. It noted the recommended ISO Cleanliness for John Deere hydraulic Excavators can be ≤23/21/16, this can be found here (Chevron Lubricants, 2015).

Hydraulic oils should be pre-filtered before being placed in your equipment even though there are filters on the inside of the equipment by reducing the amount of contamination entering the system from the onset, you can ensure a longer life for your hydraulic oil. Hydraulic oils should also be stored in closed containers not those that are left open to the atmosphere!

Advancements in Hydraulic Oils

According to (Fitzpatrick & Thom, 2021), the hydraulic oil market was approximately worth USD 77.5 billion by the end of 2021. Mobile hydraulics account for 65% of the market while industrial equipment represents 35% of the market. Clearly, the larger market share exists for mobile hydraulics. However, OEMs are also moving towards smaller oil sumps with longer oil drain intervals that can impact on the volume of hydraulics needed periodically.

Changes by OEMs also impact the formulation of hydraulic oils. For instance, if a smaller sump is used then, the hydraulic oil must now be able to cool faster, transport the same (or larger) force and maintain the intended viscosity of operation while being under greater stress. In these cases, the additive packages involving the antiwear, thermal stability, viscosity index improvers, defoamants and dispersants must be formulated to work in unison without compromising the other.

There have been changes in additive technology that allow for larger tolerances for various characteristics but while additives are evolving, the refining of base oils is also trying to keep up. With all of these evolutions, the chemical composition of hydraulic oil today vastly differs from one created in the 1950s. The requirements of hydraulic oil have also greatly evolved, forcing these changes in formulation.

Hydraulic oils today need to provide longer oil drain intervals, better stick/slip characteristics, increased efficiency, improved conductivity and wear performance and an added level of sustainability. Formulators need to create hydraulic oils that can adhere to these characteristics while also not infringing on regulatory requirements. This makes hydraulic oils one of the most powerful types of oils because they must conform to these requirements while also transferring force from one place to another.

References

Chevron Lubricants. (2015, January 24). Chevron Lubricants Latin America. Retrieved from Chevron Lubricants: https://latinamerica.chevronlubricants.com

Fitzpatrick, A., & Thom, M. (2021, November 08). How the Global Hydraulic Fluid Market Is Changing—And What It Means for the Future. Retrieved from Power Transmission Engineering: https://www.powertransmission.com/blogs/1-revolutions/post/189

Mang, T., & Dresel, W. (2007). Lubricants and Lubrication Second Edition. Weinheim: WILEY-VCH.

Pirro, D. M., Webster, M., & Daschner, E. (2016). Lubrication Fundamentals, Third Edition Revised and Expanded, ExxonMobil. Boca Raton: CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group.

Find out more in the full article, "Are Hydraulic oils the most Powerful oils?" featured in Equipment Today Magazine by Sanya Mathura, CEO & Founder of Strategic Reliability Solutions Ltd.

Oil Properties

Are Consolidation and Cheaper Hydraulic Oils Worthwhile Considerations?

Given the various types of hydraulic oils that exist, can they all be consolidated into one hydraulic oil that can serve the purpose for all the applications? The short answer is no, the longer answer is that if there is overlap among OEM recommendations within the same viscosity, then there is a possibility of consolidation. Typically, OEMs will provide guidelines on the oils recommended for use and they should be sought out for these consolidations as they will be more familiar with compatibility issues, as well.

On the other hand, it may mean that the hydraulic storage area of the warehouse has numerous hydraulic oils. In this case, a proper labelling system should be in place to ensure that the correct oil gets to the right location. Since these are specialized, using an incorrect oil (or an oil that does not meet the right specification) can result in disastrous outcomes for the equipment especially for compatibility challenges.

Are Consolidation and Cheaper Hydraulic Oils Worthwhile Considerations

One of the most common issues with hydraulic equipment is the existence of leaks. Depending on the application, some owners prefer not to fix the leaks and use cheap hydraulic oil to keep the equipment working. However, this is not the best practice.

When hydraulic oil leaks out into the environment, this can be hazardous to the people on the site (spills or trips), equipment (skids or contamination) and the environment since it was not disposed of properly. By using cheap oil, this can also damage the equipment even more as that oil may not meet the OEM requirements. In these cases, more harm is being done to the environment and the equipment and there can be significant losses financially and operationally.

This is where the quality of the oil and operations (no leaks) can trump quantity (excess volumes of cheaper oil). Unless the leaks are fixed, then the volume of cheaper oil will continue to increase and there will be additional labour costs to constantly maintain the sump levels as well as delays to the project.

Therefore, the overall impact on the efficiency of the hydraulic equipment will be reduced. However, if the leaks are fixed and a quality hydraulic oil is used, then the machine can operate more efficiently, complete the assigned projects and possibly even reduce extra labour costs related to maintenance.

Ideally, consolidation can be achieved as long as the OEM requirements are being fulfilled. However, cheaper oil that does not meet the required OEM standard for a particular piece of equipment is not an ideal option as it can cause more harm than good in the long run.

Find out more in the full article, "Are Hydraulic oils the most Powerful oils?" featured in Equipment Today Magazine by Sanya Mathura, CEO & Founder of Strategic Reliability Solutions Ltd.

Oil Properties

Are There Different Types of Hydraulic Oils?

Similar to there being endless types of greases, there are also many types of hydraulic oils specifically designed for certain systems. Hydraulics comprise of lots of different operations as such, they will be called upon to perform in various applications. Some of these can include being fire resistant, biodegradable or even being able to also act as an engine oil. These properties can be influenced by the type of base oil used to produce these oils. For example, fire resistant or rapidly biodegradable fluids or even specialty hydraulic fluids can use PAOs (Polyalphaolefins), PAGs (Polyalkylglycols), POE (ester oils) or other synthetic oils as their base oil.

As per (Mang & Dresel, 2007), hydraulics require special types of additives for their applications. The most important additives for hydraulic oils are:

“Surface active additives” – For hydraulic oils these can be rust inhibitors, metal deactivators, wear inhibitors, friction modifiers, detergents / dispersants, etc.

“Base Oil active additives” – For hydraulic oils, these can be antioxidants, defoamers, VI Improvers, Pourpoint improvers, etc.

Typically, the additives for hydraulic oils can be broadly classed into those which contain zinc and ash and those which do not. Zinc and Ash free oils can represent 20-30% of hydraulic oils on the market and are used for specialty applications where the presence of zinc or ash can hamper the functionality of the equipment.

One such example is the use of these oils in the JCB Fastrac 3000 series for the hydraulic oils. These systems contain yellow metals which can be easily degraded with the presence of zinc or the filterability of the oil can be impacted due to the presence of water. Hence, zinc and ash free oils must be used in these instances.

The following shows a chart of the types of hydraulic fluids as per (Mang & Dresel, 2007) broken down by hydrokinetic applications, hydrostatic applications and mobile systems.

Figure 1: Classifications of hydraulic fluids as per (Mang & Dresel, 2007) Chapter 11, figure 11.9.

As seen above, there are many different classifications of hydraulic oils. To provide some clarification on the symbols used in DIN 51 502 and ISO 6743/4, (Mang & Dresel, 2007) produced this table.

Figure 2: Classification of mineral oil-based hydraulic fluids as per (Mang & Dresel, 2007), Chapter 11, Table 11.3.

When looking at hydraulic oil classifications, these categories will come up and it is important to be able to understand what each of these mean as well as how it translates to your system. Typically, the most common are the ISO HM and ISO HV.

The ISO HM refers to oils with improved anti-wear properties used in general hydraulic systems with highly loaded components and where there is a need for good water separation operating in the range of -20 to 90°C.

The ISO HV oils are HM oils with additives that improve viscosity-temperature behavior. Ideally, these are used in environments that experience significant changes in temperatures, such as construction or marine, between the ranges of -35 to 120°C.

Find out more in the full article, "Are Hydraulic oils the most Powerful oils?" featured in Equipment Today Magazine by Sanya Mathura, CEO & Founder of Strategic Reliability Solutions Ltd.

Oil Properties

What Are The Functions of Hydraulic Oils?

Hydraulic oils are used in many areas of our life, from the telescopic booms of cranes to the control valves in a tractor. These oils are special as they perform a particular function which is unique to them. In addition to the regular functions of an oil, hydraulic oils can transmit power which truly sets them apart. In this article, we will take a deeper dive into the world of hydraulic oils, how they can be used, ways that they should be stored and handled and of course some advancements that we’ve seen over the years.

What Are The Functions of Hydraulic Oils?

Before going any further, we must understand how hydraulic oils function and the impact that they create for our equipment. As per (Pirro, Webster, & Daschner, 2016), the concept of hydraulics revolves around the transmission of force from one point to another where the fluid is the transmitter of this force. Ideally, this is based off Pascal’s Law where, “The pressure applied to a confined fluid is transmitted undiminished in all directions and acts with equal force and at right angles to them.”

As applied to hydraulic oils, once a force is exerted on an oil, the oil can transmit this force to either help an actuator turn or stop an excavator from moving (through braking). This is the transmission of pressure, but hydraulic oils can also provide the functions of reduced wear, prevention of rust and corrosion, reduction in wear and friction and an overall improvement in system efficiency.

For anyone who has worked with hydraulic oils, they will be familiar with the fact that these oils have very tight clearances which requires them to be clean. As they are transmitting power through the fluid, having clean hydraulic oil is essential, so this flow is not disrupted. Since the force will be the same throughout the lubricant, having these tighter clearances allows for more force to be output per square area at the intended target without the contaminants.

Overall, hydraulics will perform the regular functions of an oil but with the added benefit of the transmission of force for these applications. But not all hydraulic oils are created equally and some need to be specifically designed for particular applications within our industry.

Find out more in the full article, "Are Hydraulic oils the most Powerful oils?" featured in Equipment Today Magazine by Sanya Mathura, CEO & Founder of Strategic Reliability Solutions Ltd.

Oil Properties

Understanding the oil analysis results of Diesel Engine Oil

Having the information above is great to understand how your diesel engine oil degrades, but how will you know that it is degrading? One of the most reputable ways is to submit your oil for testing in the lab. Depending on the type of diesel engine (on-highway, marine or off-highway), different tests will be involved. However, here are the basic ones that you should be familiar with.

When determining the health of your diesel engine oil, the first thing to check is the oil’s viscosity, total base number (TBN), whether all the additives are at the correct levels, if there are any wear metals or contaminants present and finally the presence of water or fuel dilution as shown in Figure 3.

Understanding the oil analysis results of Diesel Engine Oil

Figure 3: Basic oil analysis tests for your diesel engine

Viscosity (American Society for Testing and Materials D445) – The viscosity levels should ideally fall within ±5% of the original value. If they exceed ±10% of the original value, then the levels will fall out of the classification for that grade of oil.

For instance, Mobil Delvac 15w40’s kinematic viscosity, at 100°C, is 15.6 millimeters squared per second (mm²/s), according to its technical data sheet. If this value drops below 14.04 mm²/s or above 17.16 mm²/s then it can no longer be classed as a 15w40 oil and will not be able to properly lubricate the engine. These values vary depending on the manufacturer, application of the oil and the lab being used. These are a guideline in this example.

TBN– This is the amount of alkalinity remaining in the oil. The oil’s alkalinity helps neutralize the acids formed in a diesel engine. This value is always depleting as acids are continuously forming in an engine. However, if the TBN value drops below 40% to 50%, then there isn’t much reserve left to continue to protect the oil. This is the threshold limit, which can vary depending on the application, but this is a good guide to follow.

Additives – All finished lubricants have additive packages. These will vary depending on the oil producer. However, a few additives should be on your radar when trending their depletion in diesel engine oils. These include zinc, phosphorus, magnesium and calcium. These additives typically form parts of the dispersant, corrosion and antiwear additives that protect the oil. Ideally trending the decline of these may be helpful but your lab would have reference values (based on the type of oil) and can advise on concerning levels.

Wear metals – During the engine's lifetime, components will wear. Depending on the engine’s manufacturer, the warning limits will also vary (this also differs depending on the application). Iron, aluminum, chromium, copper, lead, molybdenum and tin are some metals to trend. If other special metals are in your engine, then you can ask your lab to include them in the oil analysis report. Typically, if there is an upward trend, this indicates wear/damage of specific components.

Operators can perform a simple test to determine if metal filings are in their oil (indicating some form of wear). They can place the oil in a shallow container and then place a magnet below the container or place the magnet in a sealed plastic bag and immerse it into the container. When the magnet is removed, if there are metal filings on the magnet, then this indicates the presence of wear metals, and the mechanic should begin investigating for damaged components.

Contaminants– These include any material which is foreign to the lubricant. Typically, labs test for the presence of sodium and silicon. Depending on the application’s environment, these values can increase indicating that they are entering the system somehow. Usually, this can occur during lubricant top-ups or improper storage and handling practices.

Presence of water – This is never a good sign because water can affect the lubricant by changing its overall viscosity, bleaching out some of the additives and even acting as a catalyst. Many labs perform a crackle test (where the oil is heated and if it produces a “pop” sound, then that confirms water in the lubricant. In certain instances, it is obvious that there is water present because it settles out in the sump/container. Labs can also perform a test to quantify the volume of water present. Typically, 2,000 ppm to 5,000 ppm is too much for most applications but this varies depending on the manufacturer.

Operators can perform their version of the crackle test by placing some of the oil in a metal spoon and heating it with a flame. If it produces a pop, then they can confirm that the oil has too much water in it before sending it off to the lab. Note: This should not be done in a highly flammable environment!

Fuel dilution – This occurs in most diesel engines due to the nature of the engine. However, limits need to be adhered to because too much fuel in the oil can lead to drastic changes in its viscosity. Usually, this value should not exceed 6%, but this can vary depending on the application and the manufacturer.

One way that operators can find out if there is fuel in their oil is to place a small drop of the oil on a coffee filter and leave it to “dry” for some time. The oil will spread out in concentric rings and if there is fuel present, there will be a rainbow ring. This means that the mechanics need to figure out if there is an issue with any of the injectors or seals in the diesel engine.

Ideally, the main idea with oil analysis is to develop a trend for your equipment and understand how the values align over time. This can help operators spot if an inaccurate sample was taken (possibly after a top-up, directly after an oil change or even from the bottom of the sump). An analysis also assists in planning the maintenance of components. For instance, if the value of iron in the oil analysis report keeps increasing then there is a strong possibility that some iron component is wearing. This can give the mechanic the time they need to investigate the engine and replace the component before it causes unscheduled downtime.

Protect One of Your Greatest Assets

Your diesel engine oil is one of the greatest assets in your fleet. You should be able to use an oil that aligns with your application while slowing its degradation rate with good practices and managing its health. Diesel engine oils form a critical part of your operation and deserve attention.

References

American Petroleum Institute. (November 18, 2016). New API Certified CK-4 and FA-4 Diesel Engine Oils are Available Beginning December 1. Retrieved from API: https://www.api.org/news-policy-and-issues/news/2016/11/18/new-api-certified-diesel-engine-oils-are

American Petroleum Institute. (February 19, 2024). API's Motor Oil Guide. Retrieved from API: https://www.api.org/-/media/files/certification/engine-oil-diesel/publications/motor%20oil%20guide%201020.pdf

The International Council on Combustion Engines. (2004). Guidelines for diesel engines lubrication - Oil Degradation | Number 22. CIMAC.

Find out more in the full article, "The Evolution of Diesel Engine Oil" featured in Equipment Today Magazine by Sanya Mathura, CEO & Founder of Strategic Reliability Solutions Ltd.

equip-today - evolution-diesel-June-horz

Oil Properties

Why Does My Diesel Engine Oil Degrade?

All oils degrade over time. They can be considered consumable items as they must be replaced over time. Diesel engine oils are no different except that they may be susceptible to certain mechanisms that turbine oils are not. The diesel engine is often placed under a lot of pressure to deliver power while keeping cool and managing emissions.

The critical areas for lubricant performance in a diesel engine usually include:

Viscosity control
Alkalinity retention, base number (BN)
Engine cleanliness control
Insoluble control
Wear protection
Oxidation stability
Nitration

Typically, these factors are monitored in these types of oils to ensure that they remain in a healthy condition.

Several factors affect oil degradation in a diesel engine. According to The International Council on Combustion Engines (The International Council on Combustion Engines, 2004), these include specific lube oil consumption; specific lube oil capacity; system oil circulation speed; NOx content in the crankcase atmosphere; and influence on the lubricant, fuel contamination in trunk piston engines, deposition tendency on the cylinder liner wall, metals in lubricant systems, and oil top-up intervals. These can further be divided into systemic conditions (which cannot be easily altered) and environmental conditions (because of processes occurring within or to the system) as shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Systemic & Environmental Conditions which affect degradation of diesel engine oil

Systemic Conditions

While lubricant degradation can be caused by environmental strains being placed on the lubricant, there are times when the operating design of the system also encourages degradation. Three such cases for diesel engine oils are specific lube oil consumption, specific lube oil capacity and system oil circulation speed.

Specific lube oil consumption (SLOC, g/kWh) is defined as the oil consumption in grams per hour per unit of output in kilowatts (kW) of the engine (The International Council on Combustion Engines, 2004). Over the years, there has been a reduction in the SLOC for engines with special rings inset into the upper part of the cylinder liner. These reduce the rubbing of the crown land against the cylinder liner surface.

With reduced oil consumption, oil top-ups, which would have introduced fresh oil into the system, are consequently reduced. This fresh oil would have increased the presence of additives and helped in maintaining the required viscosity of the current oil. However, since the SLOC is reduced, the oil does not get a “boost” during its lifespan and will continue to degrade at its current rate. Hence, a lower SLOC may encourage the degradation of diesel engine oil.

Specific lube oil capacity, also known as the sump size, which is the nominal quantity in kilograms (kg) of lubricant circulated in the engine per unit of output in kW. According to The International Council on Combustion Engines, the specific oil capacity does not directly affect the equilibrium level of degradation. However, it can influence the rate at which deterioration occurs as smaller sump sizes can increase the rate at which degradation achieves an equilibrium level. Typically for dry sump designs, the specific oil capacity is around 0.5 kg/kW to 1.5 kg/kW. These values are closer to 0.1 kg/kW to 1.0 kg/kW for wet sumps.

System oil circulation speed refers to the time taken for one circulation of the total bulk oil. In diesel engines, lubricants are usually subjected to blow-by gas (including soot and NOx) during their time in the crankcase. If the lubricant spends a longer time in the crankcase, it can become degraded at a faster rate. Typically, the time required for one circulation of bulk oil averages between 1.5 minutes to 6 minutes. However, we have seen the trend toward smaller sump sizes and, by extension, shorter circulation times, which should reduce the degradation rate.

Environmental Conditions

The environmental conditions that lubricants must endure can also influence their degradation. These conditions can either be enforced through the system, its operating conditions or from conditions outside the system. There are a few environmental conditions which must be addressed (The International Council on Combustion Engines, 2004).

NOx content in the crankcase atmosphere and influence on the lubricant has more applicability to gasoline engines compared to diesel engines but they should not be fully ruled out. Diesel engines are more susceptible to sulfur-derived acids (caused by the burning of diesel fuel). However, NOx can be produced by the oxidation of atmospheric nitrogen during combustion, which can affect degradation.

Field studies show a correlation between nitration levels, an increase in viscosity and an increase in acid in the oil. NOx can also behave as a precursor and catalyst that promotes oxidation through the formation of free radicals in the lubricant. On the other hand, there can be direct nitration of the lubricant and its oxidation products to produce soluble nitrates and nitro compounds. These can eventually polymerize to form similar by-products of oxidation. This can lead to increased acidity (lowering the BN) and increased viscosity of the lubricant.

Fuel contamination in trunk piston engines happens quite often in diesel engines. If the fuel injectors are defective or the seals do not effectively seal to keep fuel out, fuel enters the oil. When fuel is in the oil, oil can become degraded quickly, often causing the viscosity to reduce to a value that compromises the ability of the oil to form a protective layer inside the component. The fuel dilution test can quantify the content of fuel in the oil. Depending on the type of engine, the tolerance levels will differ.

Deposition tendency on the cylinder liner wall is usually caused by unburnt fuel or excess oil in this area or the chamber. Typically, the piston rings scrape these deposits back into the oil, leading to an increase in the volume of insolubles. This also increases the viscosity of the oil, and it appears a darker color.

Reducing the SLOC also decreases the deposits on the liner wall because special rings (near the top of the liner) are installed to have controlled clearance of the piston crown. This reduces the crown land deposit which can also minimize bore polish and hot carbon wiping.

In addition, with a reduction in SLOC, the number of oil top ups is also reduced. As such, the replenishment rate of additives (in particular the BN) is not as frequent. Therefore, the degradation of the oil will advance at a slightly faster rate due to the lower SLOC which affects the rate of top up.

Metals in lubricant systems can also act as a catalyst for the degradation of the oil. During the oxidation process, copper is one of the most common catalysts in addition to other wear metals (such as iron) which can increase the rates of oxidation. As such, the presence of these metals increases the degradation rate as well.

Oil top-up intervals must be managed in such a way that it does not disturb the balance of the system. Typically, when the sump level falls below 90% to 95% (depending on the manufacturer), a top-up is needed. When fresh oil enters the system, it replenishes some additives and breathes new life into the oil. However, with this change in temperature of new oil coming into the system (especially in large quantities of about 15%), the deposits held in suspension tend to precipitate.

Additionally, foaming (caused by the increased concentration of some additives) can occur if too much fresh oil is added at once. As such, oil top-up intervals must be managed to avoid further degradation.

Find out more in the full article, "The Evolution of Diesel Engine Oil" featured in Equipment Today Magazine by Sanya Mathura, CEO & Founder of Strategic Reliability Solutions Ltd.